Understanding the difference between data, benchmarking, and research
The members of the DOR work together to gather, verify and make available reliable datasets and provide benchmarking data. Members of the DOR may apply as individual investigators for access to the data for research purposes through the usual process, but with respect to MANA Stats, the Division of Research is primarily concerned with supporting the infrastructure necessary for reliable data collection, contributor support, creation and oversight of data review protocols, and facilitation of access to the datasets access.
Data (or dataset): In lay terms, data means the information gathered. It may be verified or reviewed by a team of trained data reviewers to ensure accuracy, but raw data alone does not contain any analysis of the information. For example, the 2.0 dataset contains all of the pregnancy, labor, birth, and newborn information recorded in the 24,000+ charts that midwives then entered into the MANA Stats database from 2004 to 2009.
Benchmarking: Benchmarking means the reporting of basic statistics for key items in a dataset. For example, one benchmark is the overall cesarean rate for all of the clients of midwives contributing the MANA Stats dataset, pooled together. Midwives might use this information to compare their own homebirth or birth center practice data to the average rate reported by all midwives. Other benchmarking data include indicators of safety and rates of obstetric procedures and interventions. The DOR has been reporting benchmarks to Midwives Alliance members at annual conferences and in membership newsletters for several years.
Benchmarks from the 2004-2009 dataset will be published in upcoming peer-reviewed journal articles and compared with other similar datasets of low-risk women. Watch our News & Events page for updates.
Going forward, the DOR’s goal is to publish these benchmarks annually in a peer-reviewed journal. If you are a Midwives Alliance member or a midwifery supporter or consumer who would like to get involved, please contact us at email@example.com.
Research: Research studies pose a question and investigate the question using data. For example, a research study might use data to answer a question like: "Is laboring at home in water associated with a lower risk of cesarean section, compared to laboring at home but not in water?" In this study example, the researcher would analyze all the birth records of clients who started labor intending to have a homebirth. Dividing them into the group who used water immersion vs. the group who did not, the researcher would then statistically compare the cesarean rates of the two groups to look for a pattern. The researcher might also compare the water-immersion group’s c-section rate to the c-section rate for similar women giving birth in a hospital without the opportunity for water immersion.
For several years, the Midwives Alliance Division of Research has released benchmarking statistics to its members annually. One of the DOR’s current projects is preparing for publication of these benchmarks on a large scale annually, similar to the way in which the National Center for Health Statistics releases U.S. birth data every year.
The first broad-based dissemination of the MANA Stats benchmarking data is expected in 2013. The benchmarks will include all relevant perinatal outcomes, including cesarean rates, preterm birth rates, mortality and morbidity, as well as rates of successful home & birth center births and hospital transfer rates. The data will be submitted for publication in a peer-reviewed journal.
One significant barrier to annual publication of benchmarking data continues to be the challenges of a nearly exclusively volunteer-run organization. If you are a MANA member, birth advocate, or a homebirth or birth center consumer interested in supporting the work of the DOR, either financially or through volunteer efforts, please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Once the journal article is published, the benchmarking data will be available here. Watch this page or our News & Events page for details.